Essentially the question comes down to what a person's identity is. As I see it, one's identity is only evident in how others see them. A viewer can only draw identity from the actions a person takes, and the pieces of their personality they choose to display. A boy may wear skateboard-brand clothes, which would draw someone to identify him as a skateboarder, but that boy may also be brilliant with the written word - a natural poet. If he were to never reveal his secret journal of sonnets, he may never be identified as a poet.
My point, however, should not go without noting how a person's self-image can affect their identity. If a person shows self-confidence, we often assume a certain level of competence. People who are narcissistic, can be identified as concieted. People who are disgusted with theirself can be seen as pitiful.
Perhaps you are thinking to yourself, "Yes, but these aspects can be interpreted different ways." Indeed, confidence can also be seen as cockiness, narcissism could be seen as romantic confidence, disgust could be interpreted as humility. Again, these interpretations of a persons identity rest in the eyes of the beholder.
The obvious problem with this is that a person's identity is inconsistant at best. It varies depending on who you ask, which depends on what experiences they have had with that person. Take the late Michael Jackson. Some would say he is a hero, risen up from a difficult family life, to absolute super-stardom. Others will tell you he is a near-alien psychopath with self-image problems and a perverse attraction to small children. And still others will account for all the opinions that lie between these two extremes.
Amongst these varying opinions there exists an argument of legitimacy; which leads to the idea that some interpretations of a person's identity may be more true than others - evidence of a "true identity." This would follow a persons more consistent qualities. A man who is late once to an interview may be seen as undependable to his interviewers. But his current employer who has never seen him take a sick day in three years could pledge to his more consistant level of responsibility.
Following that line of argument, though, still leaves outsiders as the final interpreters of one's identity. If the skate-boarding boy burns every sonnet after he writes them, he will never, even amongst his closest friends, be known as a great poet.
Aristotle called man "zoon politikon" - a social creature, a "city beast" if you will. Given that human beings are inherently social and interdependent, how could we doubt the role that others' perceptions of us play in defining our identities? No one exists in a vacuum: if we are generous, malevolent, or patient, we possess these qualities in proportion to others' perceived generosity, malevolence or patience. It is our experience of others, as well as others' experience of people in general, that allow us to determine where we each fall on the spectrum.
My time abroad is what has most contributed to my answer to this question. I set out for Spain (and later for Latin America) with a strong sense of who I was as a person. Yet, after just a few months spent acculturating myself to my new home, I realized that some aspects of my personality that I once considered fundamental to my nature were much more up for grabs than I could have foreseen. For example, while I prided myself on my strong sense of independence back home, in Latin America that same dogged do-it-yourself attitude distanced me from others, making me seem aloof and self-absorbed in comparison to those who surrounded me. What was highly valued in one social context registered as just silly in another. In order to preserve my positive social relationships I found it necessary to let go of that aspect of my identity, or at least table it for a time, and practice behaviors more in keeping with my new context in order to create the kind of relationships that I value.
In a sense, then, I suppose I consciously changed my identity in response to others' perceptions of me. We typically look at this as a negative behavior, but I would argue that there's nothing necessarily deceptive or manipulative about this. In fact, we do it all the time: it's how we get to be who we are in the first place. As children, we discover that people want to play with us when we are nice to them, and choose not to share our company when we kick and bite and steal their toys. In my case, rather than abandoning some central aspect of my character, I was forced to question whether it was reasonable to posit my self-identity based on my independent streak, or whether another way of being Jessica was possible. I never would have asked myself that question if others had not perceived me differently from how people had done up until then.
I think your observation about others' differing interpretations of our traits is especially interesting. We each bring our own prejudices to our relationships with others, and often end up projecting our own intentions and desires onto them. For example, what motivates me to raise my hand in class and answer a question might be my genuine enthusiasm for the topic at hand, but a less confident student might interpret my action as me trying to show off my superior intellect. Taking up again your example of Michael Jackson, this very human tendency to project could be what produced such disparate visions of the King of Pop - and, in great measure, his super-celeb status. Black, white, masculine, feminine, hero, villain...how do you suppose he perceived himself in the end, while we were all making him into whatever we needed him to be for our own small purposes?
By means of conclusion, I would argue that while it is dangerous to allow others' perceptions to override one's own sense of self, a clear sense of oneself would be impossible without others to hold up the mirror - and that identity is much more fluid and adaptable than we often acknowledge.
This blog will be a joint endeavor. By asking one another questions and answering them, it is our hope to become stronger, more frequent and more disciplined writers.
Essentially the question comes down to what a person's identity is. As I see it, one's identity is only evident in how others see them. A viewer can only draw identity from the actions a person takes, and the pieces of their personality they choose to display. A boy may wear skateboard-brand clothes, which would draw someone to identify him as a skateboarder, but that boy may also be brilliant with the written word - a natural poet. If he were to never reveal his secret journal of sonnets, he may never be identified as a poet.
ReplyDeleteMy point, however, should not go without noting how a person's self-image can affect their identity.
If a person shows self-confidence, we often assume a certain level of competence. People who are narcissistic, can be identified as concieted. People who are disgusted with theirself can be seen as pitiful.
Perhaps you are thinking to yourself, "Yes, but these aspects can be interpreted different ways." Indeed, confidence can also be seen as cockiness, narcissism could be seen as romantic confidence, disgust could be interpreted as humility. Again, these interpretations of a persons identity rest in the eyes of the beholder.
The obvious problem with this is that a person's identity is inconsistant at best. It varies depending on who you ask, which depends on what experiences they have had with that person. Take the late Michael Jackson. Some would say he is a hero, risen up from a difficult family life, to absolute super-stardom. Others will tell you he is a near-alien psychopath with self-image problems and a perverse attraction to small children. And still others will account for all the opinions that lie between these two extremes.
Amongst these varying opinions there exists an argument of legitimacy; which leads to the idea that some interpretations of a person's identity may be more true than others - evidence of a "true identity." This would follow a persons more consistent qualities. A man who is late once to an interview may be seen as undependable to his interviewers. But his current employer who has never seen him take a sick day in three years could pledge to his more consistant level of responsibility.
Following that line of argument, though, still leaves outsiders as the final interpreters of one's identity. If the skate-boarding boy burns every sonnet after he writes them, he will never, even amongst his closest friends, be known as a great poet.
Aristotle called man "zoon politikon" - a social creature, a "city beast" if you will. Given that human beings are inherently social and interdependent, how could we doubt the role that others' perceptions of us play in defining our identities? No one exists in a vacuum: if we are generous, malevolent, or patient, we possess these qualities in proportion to others' perceived generosity, malevolence or patience. It is our experience of others, as well as others' experience of people in general, that allow us to determine where we each fall on the spectrum.
ReplyDeleteMy time abroad is what has most contributed to my answer to this question. I set out for Spain (and later for Latin America) with a strong sense of who I was as a person. Yet, after just a few months spent acculturating myself to my new home, I realized that some aspects of my personality that I once considered fundamental to my nature were much more up for grabs than I could have foreseen. For example, while I prided myself on my strong sense of independence back home, in Latin America that same dogged do-it-yourself attitude distanced me from others, making me seem aloof and self-absorbed in comparison to those who surrounded me. What was highly valued in one social context registered as just silly in another. In order to preserve my positive social relationships I found it necessary to let go of that aspect of my identity, or at least table it for a time, and practice behaviors more in keeping with my new context in order to create the kind of relationships that I value.
In a sense, then, I suppose I consciously changed my identity in response to others' perceptions of me. We typically look at this as a negative behavior, but I would argue that there's nothing necessarily deceptive or manipulative about this. In fact, we do it all the time: it's how we get to be who we are in the first place. As children, we discover that people want to play with us when we are nice to them, and choose not to share our company when we kick and bite and steal their toys. In my case, rather than abandoning some central aspect of my character, I was forced to question whether it was reasonable to posit my self-identity based on my independent streak, or whether another way of being Jessica was possible. I never would have asked myself that question if others had not perceived me differently from how people had done up until then.
I think your observation about others' differing interpretations of our traits is especially interesting. We each bring our own prejudices to our relationships with others, and often end up projecting our own intentions and desires onto them. For example, what motivates me to raise my hand in class and answer a question might be my genuine enthusiasm for the topic at hand, but a less confident student might interpret my action as me trying to show off my superior intellect. Taking up again your example of Michael Jackson, this very human tendency to project could be what produced such disparate visions of the King of Pop - and, in great measure, his super-celeb status. Black, white, masculine, feminine, hero, villain...how do you suppose he perceived himself in the end, while we were all making him into whatever we needed him to be for our own small purposes?
By means of conclusion, I would argue that while it is dangerous to allow others' perceptions to override one's own sense of self, a clear sense of oneself would be impossible without others to hold up the mirror - and that identity is much more fluid and adaptable than we often acknowledge.